
Botswana, long held up as one of Africa’s most stable democracies, is now the country where people feel least safe walking alone at night. Gallup’s 2026 Global Safety Report, based on interviews with 143,620 adults in 140 countries and territories, puts it last, displacing South Africa, which had held the bottom spot for several years.
Only 28% of Batswana said they felt safe after dark in 2025, down from 34% a year earlier. It is the lowest figure Gallup has recorded for the country since it began tracking perceptions of personal safety in 2006.
The ranking hides a paradox. Botswana’s murder rate is roughly a third of South Africa’s. Its police report a fall in violent crime. When Gallup asked Batswana to name their country’s most important problem, just 2% chose crime, violence or public safety.
“Low perceptions of safety have been a longstanding pattern in Botswana,” Julie Ray, Gallup’s managing editor for world news and author of the report, tells The Africa Report. “The 2025 result was the lowest we’ve measured, but the percentage feeling safe walking alone at night has exceeded 40% only once in the past two decades.”
The gender gap is stark. Only one in five women (20%) felt safe walking alone at night, against 38% of men. Both figures fell from 2024, when they stood at 27% and 43%, respectively.
Fear without a crime wave
The numbers do not describe a crime wave. Police figures cited by Gallup show reported murders rose from 322 in 2023 to 337 in 2024. For a population of about 2.4 million, that is roughly 14 per 100,000 – close to the African average and about a third of South Africa’s rate, which has hovered around 40 in recent years. In 2025, according to Dinah Marathe, the police commissioner, violent and serious crimes fell by 6%, even as overall recorded crime rose by the same margin.
Low perceptions of safety have been a longstanding pattern in Botswana
What has changed, officials argue, is the character of the violence. Marathe told senior officers in February that crime was becoming more brutal, driven largely by gender-based violence and drug abuse, and warned that the fear it generated was eroding public trust in the police. Roughly 30% of all reported crime in Botswana is linked to gender-based violence, she told parliament’s Public Accounts Committee in June.
President Duma Boko has been unusually blunt. Addressing a kgotla meeting in April 2025, he lamented men killing one another in drunken quarrels: “It seems like we are a nation that leads with violence instead of dialogue.”
The police are also stretched. Marathe likes to cite an index ranking Botswana’s force second in Africa, after Mauritius. Yet she told the same committee that “we continue to experience shortages of supervisors, investigators, patrol officers and other essential personnel”, even as 28 new police stations were due to open.
Guy Lamb, director of the Conflict Peacebuilding & Risk Unit at Stellenbosch University, suggests that spikes in street crime, possibly amplified by media and social media coverage, alongside declining trust in the police, may explain why Batswana feel unsafe.
A troubled transition
The findings come at a moment of political and economic strain. In October 2024, the Botswana Democratic Party lost power after nearly six decades in government. A slump in diamond revenues has since squeezed public finances, and in August 2025 shortages of essential medicines forced Boko to declare a public health emergency.
Gallup draws no causal link. “We’re measuring how safe people feel in their communities, and those perceptions can change with conditions,” Ray says. But its own global analysis finds national prosperity to be one of the strongest predictors of how safe people feel. In Botswana, the same pattern shows up at household level: Afrobarometer found in 2022 that 64% of Batswana living in high poverty had felt unsafe in their neighbourhood in the previous year, against 38% of the well-off.
There are already signs of recovery. Preliminary Gallup findings for 2026 show that 35% of Batswana now feel safe walking alone at night. “That’s a significant improvement, although Botswana still ranks among the bottom 10 countries surveyed so far this year,” Ray says.
A southern African belt
Botswana is part of a wider regional pattern. Seven African countries rank among the world’s 10 worst performers, five of them in southern Africa. South Africa came second from last, with 35% of adults feeling safe at night. Lesotho and Zimbabwe each recorded 37%, the Republic of the Congo 39%, Liberia 41% and Zambia 43%. Ecuador and Chile also feature in the bottom 10.
For governments, the message is that this isn’t an either-or proposition. Addressing national security threats is important, but so are the everyday conditions that allow people to feel safe where they live
Across sub-Saharan Africa, 54% of adults felt safe walking alone at night, against 69% globally. Only Latin America and the Caribbean, at 50%, fared worse. Ray notes that the two regions have dominated the bottom of Gallup’s rankings for years; both have some of the world’s highest homicide rates, which Gallup finds closely associated with low perceived safety. At the other extreme, 96% of adults in the United Arab Emirates and Singapore said they felt safe.
In South Africa, Lamb says, perceptions are shaped mainly by people’s own experience of crime and policing, or that of friends and relatives, combined with crime coverage on broadcast and social media. Poor street lighting and run-down neighbourhoods add to the sense of vulnerability. “Lesotho has historically had high levels of violent crime, and hence low perception levels of safety are not unexpected,” he says.
Liberia and Sierra Leone bottom on law and order
On Gallup’s broader Law and Order Index, which combines confidence in the police, perceived safety and experience of theft and assault, Liberia and Sierra Leone shared the world’s lowest score in 2025: 55 out of 100, against a global average of 80.
In Sierra Leone, 55% of respondents said money or property had been stolen from them or a household member in the previous year – the highest share in the world for the second year running. In Liberia, the figure was 47%, while 25% reported being assaulted, down from 43% in 2024.
Congo-Brazzaville (56), Uganda (59), Botswana and Chad (60) and the Democratic Republic of Congo (61) also scored poorly. Egypt (86), Algeria (85) and Tanzania (83) led the continent, with Ethiopia and Mauritius at 80.
Why war is not the main driver
Gallup found that prosperity and homicide rates were more consistently associated with how safe people feel than armed conflict. Once those two factors were accounted for, conflict had no statistically significant independent effect on perceived personal safety.
The African figures bear this out. Ethiopia, despite years of fighting in Amhara and Oromia, matches peaceful Mauritius on law and order. Chad and the DRC, both contending with armed violence on parts of their territory, score no worse than Botswana.
Botswana makes the point from the other direction. Its people feel less safe than anyone else surveyed, yet their worries lie elsewhere: 39% named the economy and the cost of living as the country’s biggest problem, and 37% named unemployment and working conditions.
“For governments, the message is that this isn’t an either-or proposition,” Ray says. “Addressing national security threats is important, but so are the everyday conditions that allow people to feel safe where they live.”
